Wednesday, February 23, 2022

Love, Loss and Survival in Defiance, Ohio - Mary Hess Gorman McBroom

 Thank you to Nancy Gorman Robinson who sent along this story of one of her ancestors for publication on the blog.  If you're having a bad day or week or year, read this and you may see things from a different perspective!

"Love, Loss and Survival in Defiance

This is a different kind of family story, and one that is quite amazing, I think.  It's about Bernard and Mary Gorman in the 1800s and about love, loss and survival.

Bernard was the brother of my great-great grandfather, Michael Gorman.  They emigrated to American in 1847, likely together and possibly with their two younger sisters, Margaret and Catherine, and they settled in Defiance.  Bernard was born in Ireland in 1824, so he was 23 when he arrived; Michael was 29.  Bernard is my 2nd great grand-uncle, but this story is really about his wife, Mary E. Hess.

Mary Hess was born in Canton, Ohio, in 1837.  When she and Bernard were married in Defiance, Ohio, in 1854, they were 17 and 30 years old, respectively.  Exactly nine months after their wedding, they welcomed their first child, a boy they named Michael, after Bernard's big brother.  (As families often did, Michael Gorman also named his first son after his brother, Bernard.) Mary soon gave birth to three more children, each one about a year apart, giving her four children ages 1 - 6 years.  Then, tragically, diphtheria caused the death of little 6 year-old Michael, their first-born, which undoubtedly devastated Mary and Bernard. They must have lived in fear that the younger ones, who at the time were about 1, 2 and 3 years old, would suffer the same fate.  But they didn't.

Two years after little Michael's death, Mary had a baby boy; two years after that, another boy, and four years after that, yet another boy.  Then three years later, in 1872, Mary had a baby girl named Clara, who was to be the last child by Bernard, as he died two months after Clara was born.  It's reported that Bernard suffered from asthma for quite some time.

Now Mary was a 35 year old widow and the mother of seven children, ages 0 - 14.  But fate wasn't done dealing crushing blows to Mary.  Little Clara died at the age of 3 years and 9 months, probably from a typical, incurable childhood disease of the 19th century, just as 6 year old Michael did.

In 1877, about a year after Clara's death, Mary married 35 year-old Robert J. McBroom. (He went by "R. J.")  We can only speculate the kind of man who welcomes a widow and six young children into his life, to provide for and help raise.  Between 1877 and 1882, Mary and R. J. had their own three sons together, bringing their household offspring to nine children.  This time, Mary enjoyed the company of her second husband for 36 years until R.J.'s death in 1913.  (She was married to Bernard Gorman for 18 years.)

   Married McBroom in Cleveland, Cuyahoga County.  She married Gorman in St. John's Catholic, Defiance

But Mary's story continues: She died in 1934 at the age of 97, considered old age today, but extremely old age for someone born in 1837, when the average life expectancy for women was about 45.  How did she do it with the added burden of constant grief, outliving two husbands and nine of her eleven children? She outlived R. J. by 22 years, and didn't even have the good fortune of watching all of her adult children live long lives.  Three of them died in their 20s, another at age 31, and another at age 47.  Only two McBroom sons, Joseph and Clarence, outlived their mother by 21 and 7 years, respectively. Joseph lived 78 years and died in 1955.  Clarence lived 59 years and died in 1941.

There are two more unusual tragedies this extraordinary woman had to bear, then somehow carry on. Her son, John H. Gorman found work on the Panama Canal in 1906 at the age of 47, but died just four days after his arrival there.  It is presumed he left a wife and two young children. (Documents are still being verified and cause of death being researched.)  He is buried at the Corozal American Cemetery in Panama.

Mary's son, Frank Gorman, was married at age 20.  Frank's wife, Myrtle, gave birth to a child 10 or 11 months later, but the child died along with Frank. Father and infant were buried together.  So Mary lost her son and grandchild at the same time.  Frank's wife, Myrtle, lost her husband and child less than a year after their wedding day. (The cause of death for Frank and the infant is unknown, but being researched.)

Mary also outlived 11 of her 12 younger brothers and sisters.  When she was 86 years old, she chose six people to be pallbearers  for when the day would come for her funeral service.  She outlived them all, and when she chose six more, 5 years later, she outlived many of them, as well.

Mary E. Hess Gorman McBroom is buried next to both of her husbands, Bernard and R. J., and close to nine of her 11 children at Riverside Cemetery in Defiance, Ohio.  We can't know how she ever coped with so much loss in her long life, but we do know she had to be an amazing lady to survive it."



Information from Nancy Robinson:
Mary E. Hess Gorman McBroom  1837 - 1934, age 97
Bernard Gorman - 1824-1872, age 48
Robert J. McBroom - 1842 - 1913, age 71

Gorman Children lived to age:
Michael  1855 -1861, age 6
Catherine S. 1858 - 1916, age 58
John H. 1859 - 1906, age 47
Rosalia M.  1861 - 1884, age 23
William E.  1863 - 1921, age 58
George B.  1865 - 1896, age 31
Frank C.  1869 - 1898, age 29
Clara C.  1872 - 1875, age 3

McBroom Children lived to age:
Joseph J.  1877 - 1955, age 78
Robert E.  1880 - 1904, age 24
Clarence R.  1882 - 1941, age 59



Thursday, February 10, 2022

George Butler - Bishop Post, G.A.R. - Addendum

 


In November, 2017, a post was written about George Butler, Civil War soldier and member of the G.A.R. in Defiance.

https://defiancecountyohiogenealogy.blogspot.com/2017/11/george-w-butler-bishop-post-gar.html

I want to thank Mike Konieczny, one of the descendants of
the Butler family, for adding to the story with
more photos and a vignette of George's wife,
Margaret.





 
  

 
Mike wrote:

"Maggie (Margaret) Mattock Butler, Sister of Almina, Wife of Chickamauga Veteran, 100 year-old

Margaret Mattock Butler, who lived to be 100, was married to a Civil War Battle of Chickamauga veteran.  She was the sister of Clemenza Mattock Conn Ogden and was from the Defiance area.  My mother, Joanne Konieczny, as a 10 year old girl, remembered visiting Margaret in the rest home.  At the time of the visit, she was in the company of her grandmother, Theodoshia Conn Humphrey.  Joanne said that Margaret was blind at the time of the visit.  Joanne remembered Margaret saying, 'Oh, Doshi, is that you?'  

The newspaper clipping (above) was in Avery and Lois' house for 60 years.  In the newspaper clipping, she says her family came to the Defiance area from Coshocton Co. in 1849, and her parents hacked a farm out of the wilderness.  She had 4 children, only one of whom was living at the time in Fort Collins, CO.  His name was Francis. In one of the old pictures (1931), another son, George (married to Nellie) Butler must have been a sometimes visitor to the Toussaint area of Ottawa County, OH."

Monday, February 7, 2022

Surnames G - I: Birth Records Located in Defiance County, But Births Actually Occurred Elsewhere

 

These are as found in the Birth Records of Defiance County or other files, originals located at the Records Center in Defiance, or as indexed by the Defiance County Genealogical Society and published as a book, available for ordering on our website.  

The DCGS index book notes the actual location of the record.  Births were usually recorded in a log book, but sometimes appeared in other files.  Remember that these are transcriptions and errors in spelling/numbers could appear.  It is always best to check the original record.

G

Gale, Ruth E. (W. H. Gale & Edna Clark) b. Lexington Co., Illinois - 17 Sept 1907
Gardner, Elenor (Harry Gardner & Ella Keefe) b. New York state - 22 Sept 1904
Gay, Mary K. (Lurve Gay & Ida Sweet) b. Williams Co., O - 18 Aug 1907
Genedy, Harriet Lorene (Noah Genedy & Clara Beath) b. McLean Co., Illinois - 
30 July 1907
Germann, Lyda (George Germann & Anna Warner) b. Henry Co., O - 5 Feb 1891
Gibson, Chancey Arthur (Herbert Alva Gibson & Nellie May Shelt) b. Lucas Co., O -
10 April 1908
Gibson, Sylva (W. A. Gibson & Elizabeth Motter) b. Henry Co., O - 6 May 1904
Gier, Gerald (James Gier & Nora Luce) b. Paulding Co., O - 7 May 1901
Glass, Mabel C. ( Charles Glass & Maggie Smith) b. Paulding Co., O - 2 May 1899
Glick, Sherman Elder (William B. Glick & Catherine Molorie Spring) b. Seneca Co, O -
11 June 1900

Going, Anna (Lewis Going & Bertha Klotz) b. Burt Co., Nebraska - 26 Nov. 1893
Gorden, Olive (Frank Gorden & Edna Ebersole) b. Paulding Co., O. - 3 Mar. 1905
Gouter, Maynard Fay (Clyde Gouter & Ellsie Davis) b. Williams Co., O. -24 Aug. 1907
Graham, Bessie Irene (Benjamin F. Graham & Maggie J. Riddle) b. Pickaway Co, O.
- 11 Sept. 1896
Grant, Chloie (Joseph Grant & Letitia Fifer) b. Putnam Co., O. - 11 July 1885
Gray, John Robert (R. A. & Daisy Sewell) b. Wood Co., O. - 3 June 1901
Green, Bertie Emil (Joseph Henry Green & Ida Ellis Burden) b. Auglaize Co., O. -
8 March 1897
Greenwood, Frank C. (Elmer Greenwood & Susan) b. Williams County, O., -
6 Dec 1870
Grenawalt, Ralph Parker (Merton Grenawalt & Pruda Parker) b. Allen Co., Indiana -
5 July 1898
Grether, Selma Georgia (Alfred Grether & Mary Martha Sprow) b. Fulton Co., O. -
2 May 1902
Griswell, Dora (O.S. Griswell & Ollie Dutsch) b. DeKalb Co., Indiana - 18 June 1900
Guthrie, George ( William Guthrie & Carrie Milliman) b. Chicago, Illinois -
29 May 1893
Gutzwiler, Rosa (August Gutzwiler & Rosea Fry) b. Kingman Co., Kansas -
16 August 1884

H
Hagerman, Rolla (A. Hagerman & J. Adenburg) b. Williams Co., O. - 23 June 1888
Hahn, Virgil (John Hahn & Minerva Belle Hocket) b. Putnam Co., O. -10 Jan 1894
Hall/Hale, Catherine ( Ben Hale & Bessie Myers) b.Toledo, O. - 10 June 1903
Hall, Edward Franklin (Charles F. Hall & Lillian Bowen) b. Putnam Co., O. -4 Nov 1897
Hammon, Clara Emaline (Elmadoris Ulysses Hammon & Sarah Catherine Dart) 
b. Henry Co., O. - 28 Dec. 1889
Hammond, Helen G. (Roy Hammond & Bessie Brown) b. DeKalb Co., Indiana -
7 June 1906
Hammond, Floyd Ervin (Nellie Hammond) b. Paulding Co., O. - 15 May 1902
Hanover, Lanoir (George Hanover & Lena Rollins) b. Paulding Co., O. - 3 Feb. 1902
Harman, Hannah (John Harman & Sophia) b. Henry Co., O. - 19 Aug. 1869
Harmon, Mathilde (George Harmon & Clara Batt) b. Williams Co., O. -19 Nov 1898
Harter, Sarah E. (G. W. Harter & Sarah Perkring) b. Paulding Co., O. - 4 July 1887
Hartley, Bert B. (Clarance Hartley & Ida B. Kelly) b. Hillsdale Co., Michigan -
9 October 1896
Harvey, Carry (Thomas Harvey & Phoebe Rhouse) b. Union Co., Ind. -12 Dec 1893
Haskins, D. A. (R. A. Haskins & Mary) b. Paulding Co., O. - 10 Jan. 1871
Haston, Hazel (Hugh Haston & Libbie Rex) b. Williams Co., O. - 17 Feb. 1905

Heilman, Helen M. - (J.W. Heilman & Kate Rohrbaugh) b. Henry Co., O. - 27 Sept 1904
Heisler, Lillian Anna (William J. Heisler & Mary Wendt) b. Williams Co., O. -
14 July 1905
Helberg, Arthur (William Helberg & Helen Rohrs) b. Williams Co., O. - 9 July 1904
Heston, Hazel B. (Hugh Heston & Elizabeth Rex) b. Williams Co., O.  - 8 Feb 1905
Heyman, Minnie H. (George August Heyman & Henrietta Kuebeler) b. Erie Co., O. -
1 December 1886

Hiatt, Glen Boyd (Harley Grant Hiatt & Amanda Helen Valentine) b. Fairfield Co., O. -
11 August 1907
Hipp, L. H. Doneldia (Fred Hipp & Belle Shoemaker) b. Auburn, Indiana -15 Apr 1901
Hofer, Catharine Elizabeth (Benjamin Franklin Hofer & Emma Eliza Schultz) 
b. Toledo, O. - 11 August 1907
Hoff, Luther Laird (Charles Jacob Hoff & Mary Arbaugh) b. Harrison Co., O. - 
8 August 1882
Hole, Ona Laurie (John Jay Hole & Matilda Jane Smith) b. Paulding Co., O. -
10 April 1894
Hooker, Emma J. (A. L. Hooker & Nancy Gray) b. Paulding Co., O. - 13 Oct. 1896
Hoover, Harold Henry (George Emmit & Roseann Ansberry) b. Henry Co., O. -
3 June 1899
Hopkins, Edward (Edwin Hopkins & Nellie Faxon) b. Oberlin - 13 January 1885
Hopkins, William (Edwin Hopkins & Nellie Faxon) b. Oberlin _ 13 January 1885
Horr, Willis Edwin (George Horr & Daisy Williams) b. Henry Co., O. - 8 Feb. 1902
Howenstine, Esther Margery (Charles C. Howenstine & Florence May Baltzly) 
b. Stark Co., O. - 5 July 1901
Hudkins, Abraham J. (A. B. Hudkins & Katie Figley) b. Williams Co., O. - 28 Jan 1902
Hulz, Etta Firm (G. Hulz & May Salsman) b. Williams Co., O. - 22 Oct 1892

I
Imber, Irena (Harmon Imber & Louisa Albeis) b. Erie Co., O. - 23 April 1888


Tuesday, February 1, 2022

Surnames E - F: Birth Records Located in Defiance County, But Births Actually Occurred Elsewhere

 


These are as found in the Birth Records of Defiance County or other files, originals located at the Records Center in Defiance, or as indexed by the Defiance County Genealogical Society and published as a book, available for ordering on our website.  

The DCGS index book notes the actual location of the record.  Births were usually recorded in a log book, but sometimes appeared in other files.  Remember that these are transcriptions and errors in spelling/numbers could appear.  It is always best to check the original record.

E

Early, Ernest R. (Charles F. Early & Maggie E. Dearth) b. Montgomery Co., -7 June 1888
Eaton, McKinley H. (Almon A. Eaton & Alice Jennetta Randall) b. Van Wert, Ohio, 
-6 Nov 1896
Eitniear, Earl B. (Wonnel Isaac Eitniear & Maude Baker) b. Putnam Co., O., -6 Mar 1897
Eldridge, Carolyn Fay (Luther Eldridge & Maxine Perry) b. Franklin Co., -15 July 1949
Ellis, Samuel Ellsworth (William Daggert Ellis & Mary Leah Topper) b. DeKalb Co., Indiana - 15 July 1881
Emerling, Ellsworth (John Emerling & Grace Singer) b. Henry Co., O. - 17 Dec. 1905
Enders, Ruth Lenore ( George Christian Enders & Bessie Lenore Kelley) b. Lorain Co., O. - 26 Oct 1903
Erter, Orland (Lewis Erter & Mary Corpe) b. Paulding Co., O. - 28 June 1894
Ervin, Robert (William Ervin & Libbie Buisler) b. Williams Co., O. - 23 Apr 1905
Etchen, Roscoe Vernon (Geo. N. Etchen & Emma Viola Bell) b. Paulding Co., O. -
19 Feb 1898    *also found under Etchey

F
Fadely, Mary Ethel (Henry Fadely & Dora Hilbert) b. Delta Co., Colorado - 18 Nov 1886
Fahey, Thomas Edward (John Fahey & Catherine Fegal) b. Paulding Co., O. -
21 Jan 1874
Fee, A. L. (Richard Fee & Sarah A.) b. DeKalb Co., Indiana  - 5 May 1870
Ferris, Charles Wm. (Henry C. Ferris & Ella Underhill) b. Perrysburg, O. - 9 July 1905
Ferry, Alton L. (John H. Ferry & Bertha Lett) b. Stryker, Williams Co., O. -8 Oct 1905
Fetterer, G. L. (A. B. Fetterer & Elizabeth) b. Timbercreek, Maistall Co., Iowa -
3 July 1870
Fitch, Infant Male (P.S. Fitch & Ella Sparling) b. Putnam Co., O. - 1 Dec 1897
Fleck, Elmer (U. G. Fleck & Elva Renz) b. Henry Co., O. - 24 Nov 1907
Fockler, Frank (David Fockler & Martha Colwell) b. Defiance/Paulding Co -
14 July 1880
Fortney, Charles E. (Daniel Fortney & Mary Kinsey) b. Ashland Co., O - 26 Dec 1867
Foust, Audrey K. (Enos Foust & Ilena I. Sillin) b. Allen County - 24 Apr 1892
Frank, Floyd S. (W. H. Frank & M. E. Linebrink) b. Williams Co, O. - 18 June 1900
Freeburn, Denton (Horace Chandler Freeburn & Lucinda Hawk) b. Seneca Co., O. - 22 Apr 1874
Frisinger, Lewis Monroe (Arlington Frisinger & Emma Katherine Frail) b. Allen County -18 May 1894
Frost, Jay (H.F. Frost & Mary Marsh) b. Indiana - 17 August 1876
Fry, Ella Irene (J. E. Fry & Retta Boucher) b. Putnam Co., O - 4 Feb 1903
Fry, Myrtel Bell (Daniel Fry & Edith Richardson) b. Paulding Co, O. - 31 August 1895